Sermon for Harvest Thanksgiving/Eighteenth Sunday after Trinity
So shall my word be … it shall not return unto me empty
Harvest Thanksgiving is the logical extension of the idea of Creation. Once you grasp that creation is a gift, the gift of life, it changes your attitude and approach to the world around you and to others. The idea of Creation as a gift moves in us in thanksgiving, giving back to God what God has given to us. It is profoundly spiritual in the intellectual gathering back to God that which has come from God. It is grace moving in us and in ways that belong to the truth and dignity of our humanity as made in the image of God. To see Creation as a gift means seeing one another as a gift, a point which Paul makes in the Epistle reading for Trinity 18. “I thank my God always on your behalf for the grace of God which is given you by Jesus Christ.”
Thanksgiving is a profoundly spiritual activity because it is at once the human response to the marvellous givenness of things and equally God’s grace moving in us. In short, it belongs to the truth and dignity of our humanity in its wholeness and completeness as found in the return to God. Thanksgiving is the return to God of what has come to us in Creation and Redemption.
It is a theological way of thinking that counters the overly simplistic and destructive narratives which have so possessed and inhabited our contemporary world; “systems and ideologies” which are, as the writer and theologian, Marilynne Robinson suggests, both “simple and simplifying” in their attempts to explain reality (Theology for This Moment (2016) in What are We Doing Here – Essays (2018). These ideologies are captured in such tropes as ‘the invisible hand’ of certain forms of capitalism, ‘the survival of the fittest’ in the Darwinian competition for life, ‘the dictatorship of the proletariat’ in Marxist political thought, and the ‘id, ego and superego’ of Freudian psychology, to name some of the most familiar. What they have in common is that they are all materialistic and determinist, effectively denying agency and responsibility. They are also, for all intents and purposes, bankrupt and gone, things of the past which linger on in the present like so many ghosts. Paradoxically, in seeking to displace theology and religion, they are parodies of what they sought to displace; substitute religions, we might say, a point which George Steiner made in his 1974 Massey Lectures. The old world, as Feuerbach says, made spirit parent of matter; the new world makes matter parent of spirit. But such materialist claims are for the most part no longer credible. They are empty and no longer command allegiance, no longer dominate our minds.
