Sermon for Christmas Eve

“And the Word was made flesh, and dwelt among us”

“Love is in the nature of a first gift through which all other gifts are given”, Thomas Aquinas remarks. Christmas makes that gift visible in Christ’s holy birth. What it means is captured in the great Christmas Gospel that builds on the thundering words of Hebrews. Jesus Christ is the Word made flesh. There is really nothing very cutesy and cuddly about that statement though it belongs to the radical nature of God’s engagement with our humanity. God with us, Emmanuel, in the simple and lowly humanity of Jesus, means God’s embrace of the human condition in all of its forms. Such is the divinum mysterium. God becomes man without ceasing to be God. That is the gift that changes everything. It is everything. God does not change but everything changes for us. Jesus is both God and Man yet one Christ, “not by conversion of the Godhead into flesh”, thus being collapsed into the world and ceasing to be God, “but by taking of Manhood into God”, as the Athanasian Creed puts it. Everything changes for us.

But what does it mean to celebrate Christmas in a post-Christian and post-secular world? Simply this, to ponder the mystery of the Christmas gift of God himself. No greater antidote to the myths and misconceptions about the Church, about the Christian Faith itself, and about our current angst and unease in the myths about culture and identity. Christianity, Judaism and Islam are all religions of the Word albeit in different registers of emphasis and meaning. Christianity is the religion of the Word made flesh. That highlights the order and unity of the intellectual and the sensual. Christ is the Word made flesh. He is the Father’s Son and Word “incarnate by the Holy Ghost of the Virgin Mary,” and “made man”, as the Creed puts it.

The challenge is to think and feel this mystery, the mystery of God, on the one hand, and the mystery of God with us, on the other hand, in the intimacy and wonder of Christ’s birth. To think and feel. To feel the thought, the intimate association of intellect and sensibility.

Christmas is not simply about the narrative story of Christ’s birth so familiar to you in carol and song, and in the various crèche scenes of Bethlehem that traditionally belong to the cultural landscape of Christmas. Such things all belong to the greater mystery to which they point us. Christmas Eve goes to the heart of the matter without which everything else is but tinsel and wrap. The great lesson from Hebrews sums up the pageant of law and prophecy in God’s eternal Word and Son while the great Christmas Gospel highlights that God’s Word and Son is “the Word made flesh … dwell[ing] among us”. The wonder of this holy night is what we behold, “the glory as of the only-begotten of the Father, full of grace and truth”.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the Feast of St. Thomas

“My Lord, and My God”

Thomas, called in the Scriptures, Didymus, is more commonly known as “doubting Thomas”. He is the apostolic Advent saint, par excellence, since his commemoration always falls in late Advent, indeed, close to the winter solstice, the darkest time of nature’s year, and the longest night. Yet there is a wonderful paradox. Somehow, through Thomas’ doubting or questioning, we are, as Thomas Aquinas puts it, provided with a greater confirmation of faith. The Collect picks up on that sensibility and understanding.

Advent is the season of questions. The story of Thomas belongs to the accounts of the Resurrection and to the struggles of the disciples about the meaning of Christ as Lord and God. Thomas was not present with the other disciples huddled in fear behind closed doors on the evening of the day of Easter when Jesus revealed himself to them. Thomas has heard from them about what they saw and heard “but he said unto them, Except I shall see in his hands the print of the nails, and put my finger into his side, I will not believe”. He seems to be insisting on the reality of Christ’s bodily existence. “Eight days later, [the[ disciples were within and Thomas with them, then came Jesus, the doors being shut, and stood in the midst”.

The marvel of this account is that it is preceded by Jesus’ encounter with Mary Magdalene whom he commands noli me tangere, “touch me not”! Here Jesus bids Thomas to do the exact opposite, namely, to touch and see, specifically with respect to the wounds of his crucifixion. In a way it is a testimony to the bodily reality of the Incarnate Christ and to his Resurrection. Once again, we are reminded of the inescapable connection between Christmas and Easter.

In that sense his feast day belongs to the last days of Advent in the near approach to Christmas, to the birth of Christ, to the Word made flesh. That Jesus says one thing to Mary Magdalene and another to Thomas in the same chapter of John’s Gospel recognizes the different forms of human knowing. He speaks to each according to the capacity of the beholder to behold, we might say. His doubting is really his questioning about the nature of God’s engagement with our humanity. Theologically, it is a telling rebuke to what will become one of the earliest heresies, Docetism, which denied that God could become human, denying the engagement of spirit and matter, of God and man, seeing that as unworthy of God thus maintaining the complete separation of both.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the Fourth Sunday in Advent

“Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world”

It is known as the witness of John. In answer to the questions about who he is, John the Baptist instead proclaims his mission as vox clamantis in deserto, “the voice of one crying in the wilderness, Make straight the way of the Lord”. He humbles himself in order to point to the one who comes after him, “whose shoe’s latchet I am not worthy to unloose”. Only at the end of the passage is it revealed who that is who comes after him and yet is ever prior to him. Jesus. Thus what John says is particularly arresting. “Behold the Lamb of God, which taketh away the sin of the world”. His witness is really a confession, confession in its truest sense, a confession of the truth which is greater than oneself.

We need the strong objectivity of the Advent Gospels. They point us to the radical meaning of Christ’s coming. The image of the Lamb of God is particularly telling. It counters all of the false sentimentalities of the Advent and Christmas season which are often more about ourselves in the quest for a sense of coziness and comfort, hyggelig, as the Danish call it, but only, it seems, for some and not for all. The humility of John in pointing to Jesus and not to himself points to the greater humility of God. God comes in the lowliness of our humanity as sacrifice. Only so is he Lord and Saviour. Only so is God revealed to us. This is not exactly hyggelig, however much we may seek it for ourselves. It belongs to a deeper consolation of the soul but only through confession.

Christ as the Lamb of God turns the world on its head. John’s witness convicts us far more than we realize because it is a standing rebuke to our humanity in all ages but especially our own. The Lamb of God takes away the sin of the world. This is a different kind of triumph and glory because it happens through the encounter with sin and evil; in short, through suffering, a counter to the illusions of the self in claiming to be whatever one chooses to be and in denial of the givenness of things. We are not autonomous, self-complete beings. That Christ comes as the Lamb of God, as Sacrifice and Saviour points to the nature of our mutual interdependence with God and one another, and, even more, to the forms of our co-inherence with God and creation. This reveals the true meaning of God as love. Love gives of itself but without losing anything of itself. Christ’s Advent seeks to embrace us in that all-enfolding and never-ending love of God in contrast to our empty illusions and narcissism.

(more…)

Print this entry

2022 Advent Programme 2: “And she was troubled at this saying”

“And she was troubled at this saying”

The Ember Days are a special spiritual reminder of the primacy of the work and ministry of the Holy Spirit as the guiding principle of the Church’s life in each of the seasons of nature’s year. As Lancelot Andrewes observes, the sending of the Holy Spirit is really the alpha and omega of all our celebrations. Along with being special times for ordinations, they recall us to the purpose and meaning of the ministry: in the spring of Lent, in the summer of Whitsunday, in the Autumn, and now in winter, in Advent. For each, too, there is a special focus of spiritual intention. For Advent, it is Peace in the World which relates to the reading from Micah as the lesson along with the story of the Annunciation at the Gospel.

The lesson from Micah highlights the very powerful concept of “beat[ing] swords into ploughshares” and “spears into pruning hooks”, images of the transformation of the city at war into the city of peace, a peace which is ultimately found in our “go[ing] up to the mountain of the Lord, and to the house of the God of Jacob” where “he shall teach us of his ways, and we will walk in his paths.” These are images which have their Homeric counterpart in the Shield of Achilles in the Iliad which depicts the city at peace and the city at war. The images here in Micah belong to the redemption of our humanity in our being restored to fellowship and life with God. It is very much about our learning the ways of God in whom alone we may find peace and joy.

It cannot be found simply in ourselves. We need these spiritual reminders precisely in the face of catastrophes and tragedies that we confront in our current war-torn world, a world of ‘the endless wars’, it seems, as the sad legacy of the nineteenth and twentieth centuries especially. We confront the endless spectacle of humanitarian disasters and the horrors of war that is simply mind-numbing at the same time as we talk about world peace. How to think about such things? Only through prayer. Only through the sober and sombre reminder of the complexities and confusions of human sin and wickedness. Only through the radical message of Advent which counters all human presumption. The Advent Embertide calls to mind the message of Pentecost, namely that the human community and city has no unity in itself. Peace and unity can only be found in God and in God with us. Only through the co-inherence of our humanity with God and so with one another. Such is the burden of the story of the Annunciation tonight. For we, like Mary, are surely troubled in our hearts about the words we hear in the face of the world we experience.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the Third Sunday in Advent

“Art thou he that should come?”

The questioning of John the Baptist about Jesus as the Messiah is complemented by Mary’s questioning about the Annunciation to her which is about Christ’s conception. “The Lord is with thee” the Angel Gabriel said. “Art thou he that should come or do we look for another?” John asks in prison, sending two of his disciples to Jesus. Mary, as we will hear in this week’s Advent Ember Days, “was troubled at the Angel’s saying” wondering “what manner of salutation this should be”. It leads to her question recalled in the great pageant of Advent Lessons and Carols, “how shall this be seeing I know not a man?”

These questions highlight Advent as the season of questions opening us out to the kingdom of God and reminding us of the darkness of doubt and uncertainty. John the Baptist and Mary are the outstanding figures of the landscape of Advent. Their questions point us to the radical meaning of the coming of God’s Word in judgment and hope, in grace and salvation, in Word and Sacrament, and, ultimately, as the Word made flesh. That coming is at once in the body and in the mind. Holding the intellectual and the sensible together in creative tension is the meaning of faith: “the substance of things hoped for, the evidence of things not seen” (Heb. 11.1). By way of John the Baptist and Mary we learn about the nature of our spiritual lives in faith. It is very much fides quaerens intellectum, faith seeking understanding. And that requires repentance and rejoicing. Such is the witness of John the Baptist and Mary.

And such are the spiritual principles that define our souls in the pageant of Advent. “Repent ye, for the kingdom of heaven is at hand”. “Rejoice! Rejoice! Emmanuel shall come to thee, O Israel”, the refrain of the Veni Emmanuel exults, echoing the Introit Psalm for this Sunday, “Rejoice in the Lord”. But how? Through Mary. Only so is Christ “Emmanuel”, God with us who comes in the very substance of our humanity as the Word made flesh. Yet only so through Mary’s ‘yes’ to God, her strong affirmation of what defines faith: “Be it unto me according to thy word”. Mary’s Magnificat belongs to the high note of rejoicing on this Sunday known traditionally as Gaudate Sunday, one of the Latin words for rejoice. We repent with John the Baptist in looking towards and learning about the need for a Saviour. We rejoice with Mary in the mysteries of God’s coming to us. Both belong to the ministry of the Church in preparing and making ready God’s way to us and in us. How?

(more…)

Print this entry

2022 Advent Programme 1: “Blessed art thou among women, and blessed is the fruit of thy womb”

“Blessed art thou among women, and blessed is the fruit of thy womb”

Elizabeth’s words of greeting to Mary eloquently express a significant doctrinal sensibility which belongs to orthodox Christianity. We cannot think of Jesus apart from Mary, nor Mary apart from Jesus. Mary appears in the Gospels and the Acts of the Apostles at a number of key doctrinal moments: Christ’s nativity, his crucifixion and even at Pentecost. In the liturgical life of the Church, the major feasts of Christ are complemented by a series of Marian festivals, a kind of parallelism. Her Annunciation is his conception which anticipates his nativity complemented by the commemoration of her nativity (September 8th). Mary and Jesus meet in the double-feast of Candlemas, at once the Presentation of Christ in the Temple and the Purification of Mary (February 2nd). His Resurrection has its counterpart in her Assumption, the Falling Asleep or Dormition of Mary (August 15th). Similarly, his conception at her annunciation is complemented by her conception which we commemorate this night (December 8th) whether with or without the adjective “immaculate”. It means pure or spotless which is part of the larger story of doctrinal reflection. Christ is like us in all respects except sin. Mary’s ‘immaculate’ conception is related to that idea which has to do with the nature of redemption.

As John Donne puts it in an extravagant sonnet, Annunciation, God “yields himself to lie/ In prison, in thy womb; and though he there /Can take no sin, nor thou give, yet he ‘will were/Taken from thence, flesh, which death’s force may try”. The underlying theological insight is that sin, both original and actual, is a negation of our humanity in its truth and purity. Christ assumes his humanity from Mary and as such, in this view, is pure. Christ is the eternal son of God, “that pure one,” as Irenaeus puts it, “opening purely that pure womb which regenerates men unto God and which he himself made pure.” The emphasis, once again, is on the necessary connection between Christ and Mary. Mary’s purity remains a major theme for Anglican divinity and appears in the proper preface for Christmas and the Annunciation. Christ “was made very man of the substance of the Virgin Mary his mother; and that without spot of sin, to make us clean from all sin” (BCP, p. 79).

We meet to honour Mary, Virgin and Mother. She is, as one 17th century writer put it, “The Femall Glory” (Anthony Stafford). For it is through her that we are blessed by the fruit of her womb who in turn is blessed because Christ’s Incarnation is through her. “Blessed art thou among women, and blessed is the fruit of thy womb”. But only as she says, “according to thy word”.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the Second Sunday in Advent

“My words shall not pass away”

We live in the end times. That is actually a striking feature of Christian hope and witness because it is not simply about the passing events of the day but the constant hope of our looking to God now and always. In short, it is about our awakening to the eternal Word and truth of God as that by which “we may embrace and ever hold fast the blessed hope of everlasting life”. Hope and comfort in the face of darkness and despair. Indeed, as Luke puts it, “this shall be a time for you to bear testimony” (Lk. 21.13). In other words, it is not simply the events and circumstances of our times that define us but how we face them.

That has very much to do with the witness of the Scriptures to “the God of patience and consolation”, “the God of hope”. In the Epistle reading from Romans, the word hope predominates. It appears four times. The resounding note of hope is emphasized as essential to the whole purpose and meaning of God’s Word written. “Whatsoever things were written aforetime were written for our learning,” Paul writes, referencing, paradoxically, the Hebrew Scriptures, what Christians call the Old Testament. The things written for our learning will come to include Paul’s words which comprise such a large part of the Christian Scriptures of the New Testament. There is an important emphasis on the theme of Revelation, what is mediated by God to us through the Scriptures.

Our readings this morning open us out to the doctrine of Revelation, to the idea of the Scriptures received and understood in the Church as “a doctrinal instrument of salvation”, to capture in a phrase both Thomas Cranmer and Richard Hooker. As such, the Scriptures are neither an arbitrary collection of texts nor a mere reservoir of information; instead, they set before us a whole way of thinking upon God and his will for our humanity. This is succinctly and wonderfully expressed in today’s Collect which is, perhaps, the most well known of the twenty-four original Collects composed by Thomas Cranmer. It reveals his distinctive signature of drawing upon the appointed Scriptural readings. It is about praying the Scriptures understood credally.

(more…)

Print this entry

Advent Meditation

“Thy Seven-fold gifts impart”

Isaiah is the most ‘evangelical’ of all the Prophets as Anthony Sparrow, a seventeenth century Anglican divine, wisely notes. It is not by accident that in the Advent Service of Nine Lessons and Carols at King’s College, Cambridge, used in Advent in 1918, just after the horrible and soul-destroying ravages of World War I, three of the great lessons are from Isaiah. Isaiah 11. 1-3a, 4a, 6-9 is particularly instructive about Advent both as an important doctrine and season in its own right and as anticipating the mystery of Christmas.

The passage emphasizes the so-called seven gifts of the Holy Spirit and the theme of Paradise restored. They go together and help to illuminate the darkness of our minds and our world. The Service of Nine Lessons and Carols is a pageant of the strong Word of God coming to us as light and life. The Seven gifts of the Spirit speak to heart and mind in relation to properties or qualities identified with the Messiah “which is being interpreted the Christ”, as the Gospel for the Sunday Next Before Advent reminds us. Yet the Hebrew text, as we have it from a much later period than the Greek translation of it, called the Septuagint and from which the Latin Vulgate translation derives, names six gifts though the Septuagint names seven gifts of the Spirit. That has come to define a whole tradition of spirituality in the Church Catholic expressed for instance in the Veni Creator Spiritus used at ordinations: “thou the anointing Spirit art, / who dost thy seven-fold gifts impart” in John Cosin’s lovely translation (BCP, 653).

But what are these gifts, these qualities of soul that participate or share in the divine nature itself? “The spirit of wisdom and understanding, the spirit of counsel and might, the spirit of knowledge and of the fear of the Lord”. The Septuagint, probably influenced by the rhetorical features of Greek poetry, couples “piety” or devotion with knowledge and makes “the fear of the Lord” a kind of concluding principle. The fear of the Lord refers to a sense of the awe and wonder of God whom we honour and worship.

They are all intellectual and spiritual gifts understood as having come from God. They speak to heart and mind, to character. That is significant with respect to theological anthropology, namely, how we understand our humanity in the sight of God, particularly in terms of the idea of the integration of heart and mind as distinct from their separation and antagonism, what T.S. Eliot famously termed “the dissociation of intellect and sensibility” which defines our modern dystopia in many of its confusions. The seven gifts of the Spirit suggest the mutual co-inherence and inter-dependency of heart and mind, of intellect and sensibility. That they are associated with the Messiah is also significant; they derive from the Word and the Spirit of God and as uniting us with God. As such they offer a profound vision about the greater dignity and truth of our humanity as grounded in God.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the First Sunday in Advent

“The night is far spent”

The far spent night is an arresting and compelling metaphor. It seems to speak to the unease and uncertainty that belongs to the disorder and disarray of all the institutions of our current culture in the sense of ‘endism’ and collapse. Yet it is really a profound reflection on the fallenness of the human condition in all its limitations and follies, its sins and evils, more generally speaking. To put it in another way, it reminds us that it is always the far spent night. It is a wake-up call to the principle of the knowing and being of things which is always coming to us but which we neglect at our peril. The day is always at hand; the everlasting day of the Lord.

I love Advent not so much because of its anticipation of Christmas, so overblown and coloured over with the sentimental moralism of the 19th century, but in its own integrity as a season and a doctrine. Advent reminds me of an essential feature of Judaism, Christianity and Islam. They are all religions of the Word, of the logos. They all draw, in one way or another, upon the intellectual traditions of ancient Greek philosophy which contribute to the distinctive framing of their spiritual understanding.

Advent shows the strong objectivity of God’s Word coming to us as Light and Life. It highlights the primacy of the intellectual and the spiritual which alone redeem the sensual and the material. Advent awakens us to God whose eternal truth and being is always ‘coming towards us’, as it were, in the ways in which we are turned to it. In this sense, Advent, it seems to me, is the counter to the modern “dissociation of intellect and sensibility”, as T.S. Eliot terms it, which belongs to all of our current confusions and contradictions. Such is the falling apart and separation of heart and mind, of body and soul, of our humanity and the natural world, and thus of the brokenness of our institutions. It means a loss of the intellectual and spiritual integration that belongs to the truth of our humanity, a loss of the sense of the co-inherence of all things as proceeding from the co-inherence of the Trinity and the return of all things into unity with God; in short, the co-inherence of our lives with one another as gathered to God.

Advent in its integrity celebrates God’s Word coming in Law and Prophecy through the mediation of the Scriptures; God’s Word coming as Justice and Judgement; God’s Word coming in sacrament and liturgy, in prayer and praise, in acts and deeds of service and sacrifice. These are the motions that define and dignity our humanity. The far spent night is the occasion for our awakening to our lack of awareness about these motions.

(more…)

Print this entry

Sermon for the Sunday Next Before Advent

“Gather up the fragments that remain, that nothing be lost”

For centuries upon centuries the Gospel read on this Sunday, known by the intriguing name of The Sunday Next Before Advent, was from ‘the Bread of Life discourse’ in the sixth chapter of John’s Gospel. It is the Johannine account of the feeding of the multitude in the wilderness with its distinctive sacramental emphasis. It is familiar to you as the Gospel read on the Fourth Sunday in Lent. In 1959, the revisors of the Canadian Prayer Book changed the reading to what you heard this morning about the disciples of John coming to Jesus and Jesus turning to them and asking them, “what do you seek?” and inviting them to “come and see” and to “follow”.

Both are wonderful readings for this transitional Sunday in the ordered pattern of the Church year. We have come to an end and so to a beginning, a beginning again of the long pageant of redemption in the story of Christ’s Advent and its unfolding through the Incarnation, the Epiphany, his Passion and Death, Resurrection and Ascension, the sending of the Holy Ghost at Pentecost, and the culmination of that whole story in the Feast of the Holy and Blessed Trinity. In a way, it is nothing less than running through the Creed, through what we might call the substantial and doctrinal moments in the life of Christ. That in turn becomes the basis for the second half of the Church Year by way of the Trinity season which concerns how the Creed runs through us and incorporates us more fully into the life of God revealed in Christ. In short, there are two movements: one, the motion of justifying grace in the story of Christ’s life, the other, the motions of sanctifying grace in us. This Sunday marks the juxtaposition of both moments.

There is another movement as well in the festivals of the Saints which are about the glorifying righteousness of God realised in the lives of the Saints. They are those who in one way or another have lost their wills and found them again in Christ; his grace is the perfection of their humanity. That pageant of glorifying grace punctuates the other two movements and reaches its climax in the great November feast of All Saints’. Like the harvest, it is about a gathering together of all things into unity, a unity in which we find the real truth and dignity of the diversity of our humanity and of creation itself.

(more…)

Print this entry